The Structure of Erlkönig: Schubert’s Masterful Storytelling in Song
Franz Schubert’s Erlkönig, a captivating lied set to the text of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s poem, is a stellar example of musical narrative, where structure becomes integral to storytelling. Written in 1815, this piece remains a compelling study of emotional depth and dramatic tension conveyed through music.
The Origins of Erlkönig
Goethe’s “Erlkönig”, penned in 1782, centers around a harrowing late-night ride through the forest. The poem’s storyline is simple yet profound: a father rushes home on horseback with his sick child, who claims to see and hear the beckoning figure of the Erlking. The poem ends in tragedy, with the child dead in his father’s arms upon reaching home.
Schubert composed his version when he was only 18 years old, but his setting captures an intense emotional landscape, transforming the tale into a highly charged musical drama.
Structural Elements of Schubert’s Composition
Schubert’s Erlkönig is structured as a through-composed lied, meaning it does not repeat musical sections for new stanzas of text but instead follows the progression of the narrative closely. This allows Schubert to assign distinctive musical identities to the poem’s different voices: narrator, father, son, and the sinister Erlking.
- Narrator: The narrative sections are characterized by neutral vocal declamation, allowing for the story to unfold clearly. Schubert uses a stable melody for the narrator’s section, ensuring the listener remains anchored in the plot.
- Father: The father’s musical identity is portrayed through lower pitches and a steady, comforting rhythm, which suggests strength and reassurance. Despite his attempts to ease his son’s fears, there’s an underlying unease in the father’s lines represented by the tense accompanying piano.
- Son: Schubert uses a higher register and a more urgent, desperate melody to reflect the child’s fear and pleas. The dissonant harmonies in the piano help convey the child’s escalating panic.
- Erlking: The Erlking’s lines contrast sharply with those of the other characters by employing a sweetly seductive and lyrically smooth melody. This musical choice enhances the eeriness of the Erlking’s false promises and sinister nature.
Musical Techniques Employed
Schubert employs several striking musical techniques to bolster the poem’s narrative, creating a vivid soundscape that brings each element of the story to life:
- Rhythmic Drive: The relentless triplet figure in the piano represents the galloping horse, maintaining a sense of urgency and movement throughout the piece. This motif is crucial in sustaining the tension and forwarding the narrative trajectory.
- Modulation: Schubert skillfully modulates between keys to reflect the change in mood and perspective. For example, the modulation serves as a musical indicator of the transitions between different characters’ voices, with each change adding depth to the storytelling.
- Dissonance and Resolution: The use of dissonance, particularly in the son’s and father’s exchanges, highlights the growing tension and fear. The unresolved dissonances mirror the unresolved plight of the boy, culminating tragically in the final measures.
Dramatic Structure and Climax
The dramatic tension in Schubert’s Erlkönig builds methodically. Each iteration of the child’s pleas grows more frantic, contrasted with the increasing insistence and tenderness of the Erlking’s calls. This is achieved through the crescendo dynamics and increasing tempo, driving the piece toward its chilling climax.
“The father’s attempts to comfort his son ultimately fall on terrified ears, reflected in the persistent minor key, until the devastating final revelation when the relentless horse gallop suddenly stops.”
At the song’s conclusion, the sudden cessation of the piano’s relentless triplets coincides with the father’s bleak declaration of his child’s death, bringing a shocking resolution that remains poignant and haunting.
Legacy and Interpretations
Since its premiere, Schubert’s Erlkönig has been a mainstay in the recital repertoire and a litmus test for pianists and baritones. Its demands extend beyond technical prowess to nuanced storytelling through music. The song has been recorded by renowned artists like Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, whose interpretations honor the intricate balance between narrative clarity and emotional depth.
The influence of Schubert’s Erlkönig extends beyond the concert stage. It has inspired numerous adaptations and arrangements, each seeking to capture the intensity of the original. Franz Liszt famously created a piano transcription that challenged pianists with its complex textures and ferocious demands.
Conclusion
Schubert’s Erlkönig stands as a pinnacle of the art song, displaying a mastery of musical storytelling that has captivated audiences for over two centuries. Through its sophisticated structure and evocative musical language, the piece remains an enduring testament to Schubert’s genius and continues to resonate with performers and listeners alike, reaffirming its place in the canon of classical music.
By weaving together poetry and melody, Schubert not only brings Goethe’s eerie tale to life but also invites listeners to explore the emotional depths of fear, love, and despair through the transcendent power of music.









